How are effective states going to emerge in Africa?

[Sorry to anyone who got a premature alert yesterday – hit the wrong button!]

There’s nothing like a visit to Africa – in this case ten days of book promo and financial crisis impact interviews in South Africa and Zambia, to get you thinking about the role of the state. In Southern Africa, as on earlier launches in Uganda, Kenya and Ethiopia, discussions invariably turn to leaders – is it inevitable that even good politicians will betray us when they come to power? Where will the next Mandela come from? It brought to mind a quote from American Revolutionary Patrick Henry on the purpose of the US Constitution: “The Constitution is not an instrument for the government to restrain the people, it is an instrument for the people to restrain the government — lest it come to dominate our lives and interests.” A good constitution is designed not for good leaders, but for bad ones. State building is about the long dull slog of building institutions – perhaps in some ways Mandiba did Africa a disservice by encouraging its endlessly frustrating search for the providential leader.

So I went back to my friend Matthew Lockwood’s great book, ‘The State They’re In’, where he quotes a depressing survey in Uganda that found that 59 per cent of respondents think that ‘people are like children and the government should take care of them like children’. Matthew’s book searches for answers to that critical question – what can turn fragile and ineffective states into effective ones?

Building on his arguments, here are some of the routes to effectiveness:

1. Leadership is indeed important, witness Botswana’s astonishing development since independence, or the wonders of the US constitution.

2. Conflicts can be a trigger for a major transformation in state effectiveness, provided there is either a clear winner (Rwanda) or a genuine peace agreement involving all parties (El Salvador) or the old order is swept away (Uganda, Ethiopia, Somaliland, South Korea). Fudged agreements like that in the DRC just seem to prolong the agony. Economic crises (Sweden, US New Deal) or civil unrest (Malaysia) can also provide the catalyst for a sudden leap in the role of the state.

3. But Matthew argues that there is another, more gradualist (and less bloody) route – the Ghana option (Ghana has just seen elections in which the ruling party – shock, horror – conceded defeat without violence in a knife edge election). In Ghana and elsewhere, the steady spread of civil society organizations, along with other checks and balances on state power such as an independent media curbs spoils politics, is paving the way for a transition towards a more accountable and effective state. Urbanization across the developing world will increase their prominence, since both are largely urban phenomena.

Matthew concludes on a note of hope: ‘if civil society and concepts of citizenship radically strengthen in the next few years, Africa may see the emergence of more cases like Ghana. These will not be developmental states along the lines of East Asia, and are unlikely to mirror their exceptional growth, industrialization and poverty reduction. Their developmental path is likely to be slower and more meandering as the state is pulled in different directions by different interest groups. The state may indeed become ‘captured’ by dominant groups that do not have a developmental agenda (in Ghana perhaps the extractive resources industry, for example). However, regardless of which interest groups come to predominate, the argument is that politics will have been transformed from its current clientelist basis, and in democratic politics, it will actually be possible for different interest groups with coherent sets of policies to fight for control of a functioning state.’

Subscribe to our Newsletter

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. For information about our privacy practices, please see our Privacy Policy.

We use MailChimp as our marketing platform. By subscribing, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to MailChimp for processing. Learn more about MailChimp's privacy practices here.

Comments

3 Responses to “How are effective states going to emerge in Africa?”
  1. I appreciate this thoughtful post on leadership in Africa, this is one of the central issues on the continent. I think expanding education and the middle class will help increase demand for good leadership and accountable government, and move people away from the image of a paternalistic state cited in the Uganda poll you mention. One question: do you and Matthew Lockwood really think that El Salvador has seen a major transformation since the war? I do believe political space has increased from nothing to something for the opposition but my sense is that the country is run by many of the same people with the same effect. What do you and others think?

  2. Duncan

    Hi Chris, El Salvador was me – Matthew doesn’t do Central America, and I guess I stand corrected. What you got in El Salvador is a lasting and apparently solid peace (although accompanied by a crime wave), but not, I agree, ‘transformation’.

  3. Paul Spray

    Look too at Henning Melber’s edited book on the Limits to Liberation in Southern Africa (or some such title) – which reflects on the consequences for policy today of the different routes to power of different governments in the region.

Leave a Reply

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.